Montauk Point Lighthouse: A Sailor's Story of the Grand Old Lady

Montauk Point Lighthouse watercolor painting by Alfred LaBanca
Montauk Point Lighthouse at the eastern tip of Long Island. Watercolor by Alfred LaBanca.
  • LocationMontauk, Long Island, NY
  • Built1796
  • LightWhite flash every 5 seconds
  • Seen from24 miles

At the very eastern tip of Long Island stands the Montauk Point Lighthouse, the oldest lighthouse in New York State. Alfred LaBanca first saw it from the deck of his boat, coming home from Bermuda. Read his story, then see the watercolor he painted.

Listen

Hear the story of Montauk Point Lighthouse

This story is also an episode of our Lighthouse Stories podcast (Episode 54). Press play below, or open the podcast on Spotify to hear the other lighthouses too.

Listen on Spotify

The artist's story

This is one very special light!

All at once, it is awesome, majestic and powerful, in a gentle giant sort of way. And, as you raise your eyes to follow her lines, seemingly into the clouds, you can't help but be filled with admiration and pride for this grand old lady.

Standing proudly 168 feet above sea level and flashing a revolving white light every five seconds, this beauty, with her unusual reddish-brown band, can be seen from twenty-four miles away.

Sailing in from Bermuda, the sight of Montauk Light from seaward was filled with mixed emotions. We were happy to see the light after a five-day voyage, but at the same time, we were sorry that our small adventure was coming to an end.

President George Washington approved the construction of this light in 1792. New York City architect John McComb, Jr. built and completed it around 1796.

As with so many other beautiful lighthouses, Montauk Light was slated for destruction by the US Government. The structure would have been torn down and replaced with a light on a tower. But it was saved, because of the pains of so many gallant people, who united and contributed time and money to save her.

We, and generations yet to come, have and will benefit because of their heroic efforts.

Today, Montauk Lighthouse remains an active light and is privately maintained. It is open to the public and tours are available. There is also a museum with some great exhibits.

Alfred F. LaBanca, Sailor/Artist, Darien, CT

From George Washington to today

Ships bound for New York and southern New England have always had to round Montauk Point, where the Atlantic meets Block Island Sound. In 1792 the new federal government, under President George Washington, authorized a lighthouse there. The sandstone tower was finished in 1796, making it the first lighthouse in New York State.

The tower was later raised and given a more powerful lens, and the reddish-brown daymark band that Alfred loved was added around 1900 so sailors could tell it apart from other white towers by day. In 2012 the lighthouse was named a National Historic Landmark.

The people who saved Montauk Light

When the lighthouse was built, it stood about 300 feet from the edge of the bluff. Two centuries of storms ate away the cliff, and by the late 20th century the sea was getting dangerously close. As Alfred writes, there were plans to replace the old tower with a simple light on a steel frame.

Local volunteers, the Montauk Historical Society and many donors stepped in. They fought the erosion with terracing and plantings on the bluff and a stone revetment at its base, and they took over care of the lighthouse and its museum. Thanks to them, the tower is still standing and still shining.

About the painting

Alfred painted Montauk Light the way he remembered it from the water: tall and proud on its green bluff, the keeper's house at its feet, and a pink and gold evening sky behind. It is one of his best-loved paintings.

There is also a snowy holiday version of Montauk Point, one of our lighthouse Christmas cards, a favorite gift for anyone who loves the Hamptons and the East End.

Visiting Montauk Point

The Montauk Point Lighthouse is at the end of Route 27, at Montauk Point State Park. The museum is run by the Montauk Historical Society, and in season visitors can climb the 137 steps to the top of the tower for a view over the Atlantic.

Opening days change with the seasons, so check the museum's schedule before you go. The surrounding state park is open all year, and its trails and rocky beach are a wonderful place to watch the light come on at dusk.

Montauk Point Lighthouse at a glance

Location
Montauk Point State Park, Montauk, New York
Authorized
1792, under President George Washington
Completed
1796, the first lighthouse in New York State
Builder
John McComb Jr., New York City
Light
White flash every 5 seconds
Range
About 24 miles
Status
Active light, museum, National Historic Landmark
Bring it home

Bring Montauk Point home

Alfred's watercolor of Montauk Point is available as note cards, a matted print or a framed print, with shipping included. For the holidays, there is also a snowy Montauk Point Christmas card.

Questions about Montauk Point Lighthouse

How old is the Montauk Point Lighthouse?

It was authorized by President George Washington in 1792 and completed in 1796. It is the oldest lighthouse in New York State.

Can you climb the Montauk Lighthouse?

Yes, in season visitors can climb the 137 steps to the top. The lighthouse and museum are run by the Montauk Historical Society, so check their schedule before visiting.

Why does the Montauk Lighthouse have a brown band?

The reddish-brown band is a daymark. It was added around 1900 so sailors could recognize Montauk Point in daylight.

Who painted this Montauk Point watercolor?

The painting is by Alfred LaBanca, a sailor and artist from Darien, Connecticut, who sailed past Montauk Light on his way home from Bermuda.

Is there a Montauk Lighthouse Christmas card?

Yes. The Montauk Point Christmas card comes in packs of 8 for $18 or 24 for $49.90, with envelopes.

More New York lighthouses

Val Pas